Sunset. Mountains. Jabba the Tribal Council Hutt. The S4 arrive; Peachy waits at attention. He orders them to sit down with their pads on their laps, and then brings in the jury. Sean's hair is all poofed up, and he's wearing earrings and a voluminous yellow shirt that resembles a caftan; I'll admit I spent more time than I should have trying to figure out who the big, black woman on the jury was. ["The blowout did make him look a little Macy Gray." -- Wing Chun] Peachy very seriously explains that this immunity challenge will take place at Tribal Council, followed immediately by a vote. The challenge will test how well they know their fellow Survivors. He'll ask a series of questions about individuals they've either all lived with, or events that happened during the past thirty-seven days. The first person to get ten points (by answering ten questions correctly) wins immunity. Peachy takes the immunity necklace back from Kathy and proclaims, "The all-important immunity...back up for grabs!"

Shots of the jury reveal very serious-looking Tammy and Zoe. Robert looks slightly amused but also kind of bored. He tucks a non-existent piece of hair behind his ears, and plucks at a flea. Okay, not the flea part. The first question is what was the first immunity challenge Rotu lost, and for an extra point, who did they vote out? Peachy reveals that the first immunity challenge lost by Rotu was the S.O.S. signal-building, and Gabe got voted out. Neleh gets both parts right, so she gets two points. Everyone else gets one point. They know that Gabe got voted out, but think the loss occurred during the blindfolded tiki-collecting challenge.

Next, Peachy wants to know the name of Sean's girlfriend. Neleh slips up and says, "Oh, my God" instead of "Oh my heck." Blasphemy! It turns out Sean's girlfriend is Ingrid; everyone knows it except Neleh, who has left the question blank. So now they're all tied up, with two points each.