Probst calls go. Krista goes three-for-three tossing the grappling hook and getting a bag, and she starts the table maze first. Even though Matt is behind, he doesn't have any urgency trying to untie the bag and get a ball. As Krista works her ball through the maze, Matt puts his ball in, only for it to fall through a hole and have to start over. Suddenly, though, he's ahead of Krista. She panics, and then her ball falls through a hole. She starts over, but it's too late: Matt gets his ball into the finish net and wins again. Julie and Mike are pleased, but Matt isn't. Neither is Krista, who cries. She says her game is truly over now. But now she can hang out with her precious Li'l Russell in the Losers Lodge! Hooray! As the music tries to play her off, she asks if she can give Matt a present. Probst says sure, and she gives him her pink Bible. She says Matt's strong beliefs might be one of the reasons why he's doing so well on Redemption Island. I guess her beliefs just weren't as strong. She burns her buff and tells us that this was "God's will." Matt says he's extremely grateful to Krista for leaving him with her Bible. I would be, too, because even if you don't believe in what it says, it has a lot of stories to read to help pass the time. Probst recites what is becoming his traditional "seize the moment" Redemption Island speech and sends Matt away. Watching him leave, Andrea feels a flash of jealousy, interviewing that she thought she had a special bond with Matt, but apparently, he'll bond with any blonde.
So! Back to the real game. Sarita has a toothache. She says she cleaned her tooth a little too hard and bacteria got in it or something? I don't know. Julie doesn't either. She interviews that Sarita is a "drama queen" and a "princess." Even Ralph has something negative to say about Sarita, saying she's too high-maintenance for this kind of thing, and may have stabbed herself in the gum hard enough to take herself out of this game with an infection. He doesn't understand why on earth Sarita would put a dirty stick in her mouth. I have a feeling Ralph would be just as confused about someone putting a toothbrush in her mouth. Or a razor on his back. Julie commiserates with Mike, who agrees that Sarita is really starting to annoy him. Meanwhile, David still hates Sarita from the puzzle challenge last week, so he gives Stephanie advice on how to worm her way into their alliance and put Sarita out first. He's doing this for his own personal reasons, of course, saying if Stephanie leaves and it's just him and the other five, he will want to shoot himself in the head. He interviews that he'd much rather see Sarita leave before Stephanie, and tells Stephanie that her best bet is to talk to everyone in the tribe individually, as awful an experience as that will be for all concerned. He then takes off so as not to be seen with her, and Stephanie mutters to herself that she'll have to come up with a way to suck up to the people she hates. Well, she's a waitress. I'm sure she does that all the time.