Sabrina notices the smoke and wanders over to the men's side for a chat. The men just stare at her, awkwardly. Sabrina proposes that they swap a chicken for someone coming over and starting a fire for them. Matt says that they already have a deal to get a chicken and it didn't involve fire-starting. Instead of pointing out that possession is nine-tenths of the law or whatever, Sabrina just says, "Okay, we'll see." If Matt wants a chicken, he needs to learn to negotiate. But I'm guessing he just doesn't want a chicken that badly.
Then Alicia and Monica stroll over and try to get fire for their tribe, but no one is dealing. Alicia decides to try to just grab fire, but Leif stops her. That was lame. The guys all laugh at her. So then there's some weirdness where Alicia says that Monica will take her pants off for fire, and then Tarzan suggests that they set up a pole and she do a naked pole dance and this is just getting gross and embarrassing. And the women are almost entertaining the offer! They should tell the guys to fuck off and leave. WTF? Troy interviews that the women can't come over with their "set of taters" and "walk around in a little bikini" and get fire. Oh, I'm sorry. Apparently, the women should have removed their breasts and left them in their own camp. Ugh. Shut up, Troy. You are gross. Troy also thinks that the women are going to quit because it's too hard.
That night, Kim and Kat talk about how they wish they had a fire just for the ambience. Except Kat has never heard the word "ambience." Hoo, boy. Anyway, their big plan is to go ask the guys if they can have fire just because it would be nice to hang out and talk. Yes, that's a great plan. Except it's a terrible plan. It's not even a plan. It's like a vague idea. Michael intercepts them before they can even get to the fire, tells them they're not getting fire, and then asks them who they think is in charge on the men's tribe. They say Tarzan? Michael can't believe they think that, and Kim correctly guesses that it's really Matt and Bill and Michael. I don't know why he's revealing who's in charge on their tribe. He should have said, "Yep, it's totally Tarzan. He is leading us all to victory." Jay pops up and reinforces that they're not giving away fire, so hit the bricks, ladies.
Later that night when the men are all asleep, Christina and Monica sneak over and successfully steal an ember from the fire. Monica uses two pieces of wood like giant chopsticks and grabs a piece of wood without waking anyone up. Look at that! Go Monica!