Yul is heading out into the water for Aitu, trying to get its fourth key. Adam goes back out looking for Raro's third key. Smash! Smash! They're both pretty efficient. It takes Yul a little longer to get the key and start back, so Adam has Raro slightly less than one key behind as he approaches shore. Parvati and Candice go out next. They basically maintain their positions, even though Candice stops the key as it's sinking, before it even gets to the bottom, so she did especially well there. Nevertheless, Adam is out after Raro's fifth key before Candice can return with Aitu's fifth. But when she does get back, Ozzy is going, which has to be good for Aitu. Ozzy burns rubber, as far as swimming goes, as he heads out to get Aitu's final key. Adam has Raro's fifth key. Yul and Candice hug each other and watch Ozzy swim, looking very much like they are watching an approaching tornado in a Lifetime movie. They're both very pretty, so it's quite a visual. I think the actual reason is that this is your first clue that it's actually pretty cold on this particular day, especially since they're all so wet, and especially since Candice is already small and isn't eating. Ozzy smashes the box and returns with Aitu's last key as Parvati goes back out to get Raro's last key.
Jonathan and Becky work on the locks on Aitu's puzzle box. Meanwhile, Parvati finds out that the first time she hit the box with the club, the key didn't fall, so she has to go back up again, reducing the likelihood that they're going to be able to make up this deficit at the puzzle. Jonathan and Becky have all the locks open, so they get their puzzle pieces out. "Parvati up for a second hit at her box!" Jeff says, and he doesn't mean it that way, he swears. Finally, Parvati gets the key as Becky and Jonathan are puzzle-solving. Suddenly, Becky gets all excited and starts jumping up and down, because she thinks she knows how the puzzle goes. Indeed, after this, it goes very quickly, and before you know it, Aitu has won reward. There is lots of hugging. Adam scowls. Adam is unhappy! Jenny hugs poor Rebecca, who still looks half-dead. Jeff tells Nate that his visit to Aitu is concluded, and he can return to his tribe. Aitu next has to decide who goes to Exile Island, and they send Adam, without thinking about it very much. I don't even know what would go into your thinking at this point about whom to send. I honestly think it makes essentially no difference what you do about sending someone to Exile Island when everyone seems to suspect that the idol is already gone. Jeff sends sad little Raro back to camp empty-handed, while Aitu gets peanut butter and potatoes and goes "wee wee wee" all the way home.