As the camera pans over three of the four remaining competitors, it looks like a bizarre depiction of the crucifixion. At two hours and forty-eight minutes Ethan asks Clarence if he'd step down for an entire pizza; Clarence claims that he would, "100\% guaranteed." Ethan doesn't seem to believe him. It takes Peachy nearly another two hours to rustle up that pizza, and still he only comes up with half. He struts out with the plate behind his back claiming, "Next on the menu: it's got crust, it's got cheese, it's cut into four slices, and it is very hot." And it's not Silas after a shaving accident and a one-night stand with Kimmi Kappenberg. Peachy makes "mmmm, mmmm" noises at the remaining four, and in the loser gallery, Kimj complains that if Clarence takes the pizza and eats all four pieces in front of them -- which she's sure he would -- she'll kill herself. But instead the remaining four pass on the half pizza. But get ready for more la la la la la-ing, because the losers inherit the pizza. Kelly tells those still in the competition that the pizza isn't cooked properly, and is doughy.

Lex then inspects his nails and accidentally pulls his water bucket down, and Peachy laughs at him because he "missed out on all that food by minutes." Because it's fun to torture hungry people. Actually in this case, it would be fun to torture hungry people. Joining the others, Lex whispers to Kelly that he doesn't want to see Clarence "wearing that damn necklace," because it would piss him off. Kimj wants to see the challenge come down to Clarence and Ethan, but at four hours and thirty-eight minutes Ethan accidentally pulls his bucket down, leaving only Teresa and Clarence in the game.

Teresa is concentrating very intensely, and Clarence has to whistle to get her attention. He requests a compromise: Rock, Paper, Scissors for the victory. Teresa thinks she has "too much to lose," because she's outnumbered by former Boran tribe members. Clarence assures her that she's not a target, but she doesn't believe him, so the challenge continues.