Josh & Brent open their clue, and come up with a strategy of looking at each order board to see which one has the closest addresses. It's the home field advantage all over. Josh memorizes the pizzas while Brent memorizes the addresses. Of course Brent is going to take the smaller set of information so he can blame Josh for forgetting something. Meanwhile, John looks a bit annoyed at how Josh keeps opening all the boxes to see what's inside. They're going to get cold, you know. Josh says that of all the pizzas delivered to them in all their years living in New York, they've never delivered one themselves. Soon they're out on the street, about to change that.
The Chippendales are also on the street, but they're still waiting for a taxi to take them from the Navy Yard to Lombardi's, which is just now arriving. These two need to get their shit together already.
Trey & Lexi deliver the first batch of pizzas to the Italian American Museum at 155 Mulberry Street, and according to a graphic onscreen and a triumphant "ding!" on the soundtrack, they did it correctly. Josh & Brent drop off some pies at the Lotus Salon at 7 Prince Street, also correctly. Trey & Lexi get directions to Lafayette. While proceeding to Mulberry, Josh says he hopes they're the right pizzas, though he has to say it three times before Brent hears him. Team Austin delivers to Bicycle Habitat at 250 Lafayette, and heads to the third stop. "I better get a pizza at Lombardi Pizza after this," Trey says. Oddly, a lot of these runs are being filmed from directly overhead, like the camera crews are making use of some Amazing Fire Escapes or we're watching Without a Trace. It's probably the former, if only to get the idea of "Escape" in our heads one more time for their friends at Ford. Josh & Brent get to 166 Mulberry, but a buzzer goes off to indicate what the onscreen graphic tells us is an "incorrect delivery." We flash back to Lombardi's, when they talked about the top three on the stack going to 377 Broome instead, but the apartment resident accepts the top three pizzas on the stack without complaint. "You must be hungry," Brent observes. "Starving!" the dude roars back. On to the next place. Meanwhile, the Chippendales are realizing they have a slow cabdriver. That's always a thrilling discovery in the final leg.
Trey & Lexi deliver their last four pizzas to the residents of 58 Kenmare Street, Apartment 1, who don't seem to mind having their address broadcast on CBS prime time. That's their third correct delivery, so it's back to Lombardi's for them. Josh & Brent, having already make one incorrect delivery, by necessity make another one when they drop off the remainder of their pizzas at a vintage clothing store at 377 Broome St., complete with another buzzer they can't hear. "God I hope these are right," Josh says as they run back. "If they're not, you know there'll be hell to pay," Brent replies. Yes, I think we all know that.