Garage. The other cop is dead. On the wall, written in blood: NEVERMORE. Ugh. I'm already tired of this pedantic bastard and we're not even through the pilot. English majors, am I right?
Turner tells everyone that the neighbors (Will Wilson and Billy Thomas -- seriously? Your gay couple is William and William? A little narcissistic, Mr. Williamson?) left in their SUV forty minutes ago, and no one searched their vehicle. Mike fills in that Will teaches second grade and Billy runs the fraud division of a bank. Ryan posits that they aren't actually gay, but that Carroll planted them to help him get Sarah. Riley protests that they've been her neighbors for three years, but Ryan thinks this is Carroll's new MO: he has helpers -- recruited from the Internet -- to help him commit his murders. Turner can't believe these guys would pretend to be gay for three years to do this, but did he miss the part where a woman STABBED HERSELF IN THE EYE a little while ago because Carroll told her to? Clearly Carroll's fans are all bananas.
Ryan lists Raines, Stabbyface, Will and Billy, all members of Carroll's cult. And then he clicks to "The Raven" and starts yelling about satellites and the finality of death and getting GPS tracking on the SUV and Turner chooses this moment to be all, ah, so Ryan's crazy! Everybody ignore the crazy man! Except... Sarah's still missing. So maybe he has a point?
Ryan storms off and we can hear his heart pounding, because of course. He flashes back to the night in 2003 when he ran into Annie and Sarah as they were on their way home -- the night they were attacked by Carroll. As he told Mike earlier, he'd started following Carroll everywhere because he suspected he was the murderer, but didn't have any evidence. Ryan lurks outside Sarah and Annie's house, then hears Sarah screaming inside. He breaks a window and rushes in. Sarah is lying on the floor, stabbed and Carroll jumps up behind Ryan. He stabs Ryan, then comes back to cut Sarah's throat. Ryan shoots him. Heartbeats.
Ryan is skulking around Will and Billy's house, looking at the photos of the two, embracing. Mike tells him both of them were listed in the prison visitor log and that they had property Lake Whitehurst. In one photo, Will and Billy are posed in front of a sign that says "The Lighthouse Bed & Breakfast." Ryan pulls out his phone and Googles a lighthouse in Lake Whitehurst.