Raines wants to know what happens if she doesn't like what he tells her, and how he knows he can trust her, and Parker's all, which one of us is the lying, murderous dipshit here? He says he doesn't know where Joey is--they divide up the secrets so no one knows everything in case they get caught. Yeah, I bet that is not how Emma sees things. Parker asks if Rick knows where Joey is, but Raines says Maggie does -- she and Emma planned the kidnapping. Dun dun dun.
Mike catches up with Ryan. He talks to Parker, who tells them that Maggie is part of the cult.
Inside the house, Maggie's phone rings. Riley looks at the message, and tells her it says "Now." DUDE YOU ARE AN FBI AGENT. BE SMARTER THAN THIS. Maggie stabs him in the throat with a wee small knife. Riley falls on the floor, gushing blood and clutching his neck.
Flashback to that time Rick stabbed Maggie. Apparently it was part of a game of truth-or-dare the culties were playing. Maggie says he went too deep. Paul and Jacob laugh at how Rick is shit with knives, and Emma just says Maggie needs a hospital. Rick is all solicitous and caring about how he accidentally maybe severed something important.
Rick is in the house now. Maggie tells him they need to go, and they leave Riley bleeding on the kitchen floor. Mike and Ryan run in the front door and find Riley. Mike puts pressure on Riley's spurting neck wound while Ryan chases the Kesters. Maggie stops and plays the victim some more, but Ryan's onto her. Behind him, Rick tries to bludgeon Ryan, but Ryan turns and shoots him. Doesn't kill him, though, because Rick pops right back up and tries to tackle Ryan. Maggie just sits there like a lump. Ryan shoots Rick again and this time he stays down, but Maggie's gone.
Ryan goes back into the house, and Mike is sitting over Riley's dead body.
Country house. Emma and Jacob come downstairs, clearly having just been woken up by noises in the kitchen. The noises: Paul, who's tying a gagged Megan to a chair. He introduces her, and Emma wants to know what the hell he's doing. Paul says he's done listening to Emma, who comes at him like she's going to finish what she started with that carving knife, but Jacob interrupts and asks her to go check on Joey. Jacob asks what he's doing. Paul's through being a fifth wheel. He asks Jacob is Emma knows what a liar he is. Jacob says they promised they wouldn't tell anyone. Boys, it's okay if you had one little drunken tryst while you were pretending to be boyfriends. Situational homosexuality: so fashionable!