Erik hides next. Once he gets the suit on, he has to shoot a pretend machine gun because he is eight years old. Kathy and Frederique listen to the first question: "If Martians came down and abducted one person, who would it be?" They both agree that it's Frederique, with no discussion. The second question is, "Who would you rather be stranded on a deserted island with?" Kathy thinks it's definitely Frederique. She explains in a faux-disappointed voice, "Because you're a hot model." Frederique says she'd rather be with Kathy than Erik. Kathy is touched, and they agree to go with Frederique as their answer. Kathy points out how horrific an eternity would be for her with Erik, since he doesn't laugh at her jokes. Ahmad asks Frederique why she thinks Erik would pick her. Frederique says he probably wants to learn Dutch, and Ahmad retorts, "That wouldn't be my answer." Shut up, Ahmad. The third question is, "Who is more likely to wear dirty underwear?" Frederique has no clue. Kathy says she thinks Erik will say her, because Frederique has her own underwear line. Frederique still isn't sure. Kathy says, "I think he knows I'm dirty." Frederique agrees and laughs and they come to the end of the path and start calling Erik's name. They're in the wrong place, so they don't win any money. They find him on another path.
Ahmad reviews the questions. They got the first one right, but Erik said he'd rather be stranded with Kathy on a deserted island. In an interview, Erik says that Kathy had the right idea with the whole supermodel thing. Erik tells them he chose Kathy because they enjoy hanging out together. Kathy adds that she's also hot. Ahmad reviews the dirty-underwear question, which they got right, and he asks Erik why he said Kathy. Erik asks Kathy not to slap him, and reminds her that just that morning she was talking about how dirty her bathing suit is. Kathy says that it's true that she will wear a dirty bathing suit. Are there really people out there who wash their suits every single time they wear them? What if you're, like, at a lake, and you go swimming, and then put dry clothes on, and then later that day you want to go swimming again? I guess rich celebrities have enough bathing suits that they just put on a new one every time. Erik points out that Kathy's worn that shirt before too. Kathy sadly admits that she's dirty.
Now it's Kathy's turn to hide. Ahmad asks Frederique and Erik the first question: "Who is more likely to stiff a waitress?" Frederique says that it's probably her because she's Dutch. So she usually goes Dutch? Erik says that Frederique is a girl, and girls don't usually pay for the meal, so they also don't tip. What? Shut up, Erik. They agree to go with Frederique. Erik is worried because they've always gone to Ahmad's left after the first question, and he thinks they are wrong already. The second question is, "Who thinks they have better hair?" Erik thinks it's him. Frederique agrees. Ahmad clarifies, "So you guys think that Kathy would think Erik's hair is better than [Frederique's] hair?" Um, that wasn't the question, dude. Shut up, Ahmad. Erik sets him straight. Ahmad asks the third question: "Who is more likely to gain weight when they get older?" Frederique giggles and Erik asks what would be the funnier answer. It's so sad that he has to ask. Frederique says the funny answer would be to say her, but she thinks Kathy would say Erik. Frederique tells Erik to call it, and he wants to go with himself. Now suddenly Erik thinks they won, even though he was all doom and gloom earlier. They call out Kathy's name, but she doesn't appear. They go and find her, and she seems very grouchy.