On the way to the poolhouse, Seth and Ryan run into Sandy, who is grilling up some meat. Sandy asks what's going on, and Seth tells him that Ryan has caused a crisis "that threatens man, woman, and Chrismukkah," by inviting Aunt Lindsay over. Sandy asks if Ryan really invited Aunt Lindsay to the party, and then tells them that he really doesn't think it's a good idea. Ryan apologizes for imposing, but Sandy clarifies that it's not that, and then he asks Ryan how serious it is between him and Lindsay. Ryan stammers out an answer (with a couple of small interruptions from Seth), leading Sandy to ask, "So you really like her?" Seth: "He wants to see her naked." Ryan turns to him and whispers, "Okay, I hate it when you do that." Ryan wonders if there's some reason he shouldn't go out with Aunt Lindsay. Sandy points out that "her mom's involved in Caleb's case. It's, uh, the timing is probably not great, given everything." Ryan acquiesces at first, but then wonders "what Lindsay could have to do with Caleb's case....What is she, Caleb's hit man? Drug dealer?" Seth: "Illegitimate lovechild?" Sandy drops the spatula he's holding and turns to glare at them. It really doesn't take them long to realize that Seth hit it right on the nose. Sandy picks up the tray of meat, walks over to them, and says, "This stays between us." You know, Sandy, if you had just kept your cool and not stared at them, they might not have figured it out.
Commercials. Is it just me, or was it a little insensitive of Fox to advertise Who's Your Daddy? during this episode? Oh wait, I forgot -- it's Fox. "A little insensitive" is actually a step up for them.