Willie and Melanie sit out on the front steps. Willie says that he's getting a vibe from Karamo, and that it's weird. In a confessional, Willie says that he doesn't know what's going on there, but that it's bizarre. Melanie interviews that Karamo's not gay, and that Willie's gaydar is messed up. Willie tells Mel to watch out for it, and Mel says that Karamo is just "really friendly." Heh.
MJ jokes with Willie about giving sexy looks. In a confessional, MJ says that it's not as uncomfortable as he thought it would be. Imagine that! Gay people are...just regular people! MJ says that he and Willie respect each other, and that MJ would have Willie's back if anything happened. Karamo asks if Willie said he was gay, and Willie laughs that he didn't say it, but that it's pretty obvious. In a particularly bug-eyed interview, MJ says, "You can call it being intuitive. You can call it having a good gaydar. But I can tell whenever somebody's gay, especially if I'm living with them." Heeee hee! I love how the dude who has never met a gay person before thinks he has good gaydar. Hey, he watches Queer Eye! What? Karamo asks if Willie is afraid to label himself. Karamo interviews that he doesn't feel the need to come out until the time is right.
At 5:00 AM, MJ and Sarah are the only two still awake. They discuss how they should go to bed. MJ asks if Sarah is a natural redhead. Wow, I didn't think she had red hair at all. I guess it's kind of strawberry blonde. MJ walks away and says that he only likes blondes, so they can be friends but not lovers. MJ interviews that he doesn't know why, but he's only attracted to blondes. MJ admits that Sarah is hot, though. Sarah interviews that she's attracted to MJ because he's made it clear that she's not his type. Ugh. Seriously. Daddy issues. Ten to one says that she has an emotionally distant or absent father.
The next morning, the roommates wake up and take showers. Ooh, they've got a shower with like six shower heads. Sarah holds a shirt up to herself, and MJ raspily says that he likes that shirt because it's "earthy." Sarah says that it's naughty, because she once had sex wearing just that shirt and pigtails. Overshare! MJ interviews that Sarah is "like a sexual predator" because "everything comes back to sex." Sarah pulls out some leg warmers, and MJ asks if she's had sex in them too. Don't encourage her! Melanie overhears the conversation and interviews that Sarah is a big flirt.