Paulie has a bad dream that wakes up his girlfriend's kids. She consoles them, and Paulie tells them he just had a bad dream. He says he's going to put them to bed, and then he's going to go home to sleep so he doesn't keep waking everyone up. He walks the kids off to bed. It's very cute seeing Paulie in boxers, leading small children by their hands. The windchimes go off outside.
Paulie tells his girlfriend that Christopher didn't have a dream. He was dead. His girlfriend says that Paulie should go to a professional psychic who can contact dead people. She says she knows someone who is really good at it. "Fucking freakshow," Paulie laments. His girlfriend says the only thing he has to lose is his nightmares.
Pussy meets with a guy I'm assuming is Quickie G, the pusher Richie spoke of earlier. He seems upset that he's forced to talk to Pussy and not someone higher up. Pussy says he'll make sure he gets points for this. The kid says that there's a house in a state park that says "George Washington Slept Here" where Matt's hiding. ["Hacklebarney. We used to go there on school trips all the time." -- Sars] Pussy gives him a twenty.
The psychic is talking to some dead people as Paulie watches from the circle of the group. He's cracking jokes to the rest of the group, but nobody finds him very funny. The psychic is talking to the father if the guy in front of him. He tells him that his father's sorry he found his body. The psychic has to stop talking to the dead person, because there's another dead person in the room making a bit of a fuss. He's scared. The psychic tries to calm the spirit down and walks straight over to Paulie. Paulie stands up and asks what the problem is. The psychic is listening to the spirit and tells him that Paulie can't hurt him. The psychic starts looking around the room like there are several spirits talking to him. Some guy named "Sonny." Paulie asks how the fuck the psychic knew that. "He says it was your first, but I feel many more." Paulie starts getting upset as the psychic says another one is talking about poison ivy, and wants to ask Paulie if it still itches. Paulie grabs the psychic by the throat and tells him not to fuck with him. The psychic asks him to leave. "Fuck you and this bullshit," Paulie says. He says it's all Satanic black magic. The psychic asks him to leave again. "Fucking queers!" Paulie shouts as he throws a chair across the room. He walks out.
Paulie pours himself a drink back at the backroom at the Bada Bing. He says that he made the appointment with a fake name. They didn't know who he was. He says that he's dragging a bunch of ghouls with him and Mikey is their ringleader. Tony says that there's no reason all of those people would follow Mikey around. Paulie asks how Tony can be so calm. Tony says he doesn't believe any of this shit. Paulie says that he was ready to write the entire thing off until the psychic mentioned Sonny. He says he did that hit thirty years ago, and doesn't know how the psychic would know that. Tony asks if Paulie asked the psychic where Matt Bevelaqua is, since that would be actual helpful knowledge. Paulie says the psychic deals only with the dead. Tony is at a loss for words. He asks if Paulie eats steak. Paulie says he does. The phone starts ringing as Tony explains that if Paulie lived in India he'd go to Hell for eating steak, but since he doesn't live in India, he doesn't believe he's going to Hell for that. He leaves to answer the phone.