Quickfire Challenge. The cheftestants are paired up by knife draw and then compete head-to-head to identify the ingredients in a sauce by taste alone. Each cheftestant gets to taste the sauce and then has to bid against their opponent Name-That-Tune style as to how many ingredients they can identify. They compete in a bracket-style tournament and it comes down to Carla, Stefan, and Hosea. For the final three, they all taste a Mexican Mole Sauce and then take turns naming ingredients (like a spelling bee) until only one remains. Carla gets knocked out on the first round when she says peanut butter. Hosea and Stefan go a few more rounds. Stefan says tomato paste, which is incorrect, and Hosea wins with his guess of vegetable oil. He gets immunity and the pleasure of beating Stefan.
Elimination Challenge. The cheftestants are split up into four teams: Old, New, Borrowed and Blue. Their task is to cater Gail’s bridal shower, where there will be forty guests, many of whom are her colleagues at Food & Wine magazine. They have to create dishes based on their team name. The teams and themes are:
Old: Hosea, Stefan and Jeff, who use heirloom tomatoes to make Old World dishes
New: Carla, Eugene and Daniel who make sushi and a bunch of other weird foods, like peach barbecue sauce
Borrowed: Radhika, Jamie and Ariane, who make Indian food, borrowing culture
Blue: Fabio, Melissa and Leah who make seafood to reference the blue ocean
Stefan rubs his teammates the wrong way when he starts barking orders at everyone. Eugene comes up with the brainstorm to serve his sushi deconstructed and let the guests assemble it themselves, which all of his opponents think is insane.
The Old team goes first and their food goes over well, especially Jeff’s sorbet. The New team goes next, but Eugene fails to explain how to put the food together and the guests are kind of confused. Borrowed has to wait on Ariane’s not-quite-done lamb and requires the help of the entire kitchen to get their food plated. And finally Blue sends out Fabio to charm the ladies, but they’re not impressed with his underseasoned seafood.
The judges decide that the Old and the Borrowed teams are their favorites, and the individual winner is Ariane. Jamie is really upset; she thought she deserved the win. That means the New and the Blue teams are in the bottom two. While the Blue team made some disastrous decisions, the New team’s food was bad in both conception and execution, according to Tom. But Daniel made a bad dish and he also added unnecessary mushrooms to Carla’s salad, so he is told to pack his knives and go.
The morning after the most recent elimination, Melissa contemplates her mortality in the competition. She interviews that she realized that she could go home and she knows now that she needs to step it up. Ariane, on the other hand, is feeling good after winning the last Elimination Challenge, especially since she's older than all of her competitors. Around breakfast, Jamie shows off her stuffed animal (I think it's a puppy? Or possibly an elephant?) and reveals that Stefan fashioned some little pants for it out of a dish towel. Stefan is like Bob from Survivor with the using found materials to fashion crafts and whatnot. Jamie interviews that Stefan is cocky, but he also makes her presents and has a huge crush on her. She doesn't seem too bothered by it. Stefan interviews that he thinks Jamie is sexy and he loves her. Jamie reminds him, in an interview, that she is, in fact, a lesbian. Stefan is just cocky enough that he probably thinks he can overcome that.
Quickfire Challenge. The cheftestants walk into the kitchen and find Padma alone, with no guest judge. She explains that they're going to play "Identify That Ingredient" in order to test their palates. Jamie interviews that she thinks she has an awesome palate, and while she has come close to winning some Quickfires, she hasn't yet. And she'd really like to. I admire Jamie's confidence, but we haven't really seen if she has the goods to back it up. She's always talking about how she should win, and how great she is, and yet...she doesn't win. The cheftestants draw knives and notice that they end up getting paired up. Stefan is pleased that he gets paired up with his fake-girlfriend Jamie. Once everyone is paired, Padma explains that they will enter the kitchen and taste a sauce. Then they will bid against each other, Name That Tune style, as to who can name the most ingredients in the sauce. The winner of each round will move on, bracket-style.
First round is Hosea vs. Daniel. Daniel interviews that he feels like a winner today, and the immediately loses the coin toss to see who goes first. Hee! They both taste the shrimp and lobster bouillabaisse, and then Hosea claims that he can name four ingredients. Daniel think he can do the same, so Padma has to explain that he needs to go at least one higher. Daniel instead challenges Hosea to name those four ingredients. Hosea rattles off onion, shrimp, lemon, and carrot and moves on to the next round.