Damon walks out into the hallway. "It's about time, Sexy Becks." It's not Rebekah, though. It's Vamparic. He grabs Damon in a headlock and asks where Desikklaus is. Damon's all, "How did you find me?" Vamparic sings the praises of Law Enforcement Officers who aren't corrupted by vampires. When Damon fess up which locker holds Desikklaus, Vamparic snaps his neck. I kind of feel bad that human Alaric never got to do that. M-m-memories... Oh and commercial.

Gilbert Gables. Matt brings Elena some tea. When she cringes after taking a sip, Matt lies that he added too much honey and then he asks her about her feelings for Stefan. She gives him the backstory on how Stefan saved her life. Matt wonders if she thinks she owes him something. Elena says it's not that. After the accident, she felt like she didn't know how to live anymore -- and that she didn't want to. After she met Stefan, she started to figure it out. "That's what love should be. You should love the person that makes you glad you're alive. [...] The problem is Damon. When I'm with him, it just consumes me, and I know that I can't love them both. I know that it's wrong, but I -- when I choose one, then I lose the other, and I don't want to lose anyone else. I--I just I wish that I had my mom here to give me some advice." Elena sighs, drinks her tea and stares out the window. We flash back to that fateful night...

Sophomoric Elena is walking away from the bonfire when she calls home. Jenna is good-natured as she complains that Grayson Gilbert (Jason MacDonald) is making her play Pictionary. "I suck at Pictionary." Aw. Me too, Jenna. Me too. Elena wants a ride home and needs to talk to a real grown-up anyhow, so Jenna puts Miranda on the phone. Matt and Elena had a big fight. He's being too pushy about their future. Miranda says he doesn't mean to be; he's just trying to suss out how she feels about him. Elena claims she doesn't know how she feels. Mama isn't buying that any more than I've bought that she doesn't know if she has feelings for Damon. Elena is afraid if she's honest with Matt, she'll lose him. Miranda wisely says that she won't be losing Matt. She'll be setting him free. We cut back to the...