X Factor
X Factor

Episode Report Card
M. Giant: B | 635 USERS: B-
YOU GRADE IT
Singing for Their Supper

First up at Casa Cowell is Simone Battle, whose retrospective clip package reminds us of how much her arrogant ass is in need of a reality check. Beyond forgetting all her lyrics at her final Boot Camp audition, which apparently didn't do the trick. She walks up to Simon on his pool deck and, accompanied by a pianist and guitarist sitting off to the side, sings a slow version of the Beatles' "Help." Is this supposed to be her showing a vulnerable side? I'm not buying it. Hard to tell if Simon is, motionless behind his aviators. "Well done, you," he congratulates her at the end. He liked it, of course, not that anyone's giving feedback to the contestants at this stage. It takes a vocal coach and two music producers to add up to one Mariah Carey, and they squat obsequiously around Simon, trying not to offend him by disagreeing with Little Simon.

Paula and Pharrell gather the groups in the kitchen, where I'm sure one of the girls is regretting wearing that black-and-white outfit with the bowtie. Standing next to Paula's counter, she looks like a cater waiter. Paula and Pharrell try to buck everyone up while warning them that they won't all make it through. The first group to perform will be best friends The Anser, who drove twelve hours to the Seattle auditions and ended up at the back of the cattle call line at five in the morning. And left their W at a rest stop along the way somewhere, too. They're confident of winning the five million dollar prize, but they're off to a shaky start when they present themselves on Paula's backyard patio and Pharrell notices that the guy with the red glasses isn't wearing them. I guess the guest judges got to see tapes of the auditions anyway, or at least Pharrell did. Singing "Less Than Perfect" to the accompaniment of a piano and a guitar, they impress Paula and Pharrell, the latter of whom is still hung up on the kid with the glasses. Or without the glasses. Who will never be without them again.

X Factor

Comments

SHARE THE SNARK

X

Get the most of your experience.
Share the Snark!

See content relevant to you based on what your friends are reading and watching.

Share your activity with your friends to Facebook's News Feed, Timeline and Ticker.

Stay in Control: Delete any item from your activity that you choose not to share.

The Latest Activity On TwOP