BLOGS
Since Saturday I've been thinking about the announcement that Matt Smith was going to fill David Tennant's shoes. I've gone back and forth on how I feel about them casting a 26-year-old relative unknown in this major geek role. My first reaction (mostly based on the age) was "Gah, this is going to be just as bad as Twilight." Actually my first reaction was "Who the hell is that?," but the young guy with nice hair thing came in a close second. But I've finally decided that I'm OK with it. I mean, I still haven't come to terms with the fact that David Tennant is leaving, and there were a host of other choices on the teaser lists that sort of tickled my fancy, but I've decided that I trust in Stephen Moffat and I'm willing to go along with this wild ride. And below are my reasons why.
1. Matt Smith's kind of adorable, but not conventionally hot. I don't see fangirls stalking him and blogging about how he styles his hair all the time (thankfully). David Tennant worked the adorkable angle and I was OK with it.
2. A mostly unknown star gives him a chance to really mold into this role. There aren't preconceived notions about how he'll be or not be based on his previous works. He doesn't have a legion of fans like Bill Nighy or some of the other big names that were floating around, so he doesn't have to live up to any hype or behave in a way that his fan base expects. He just has to make Doctor Who fans happy. One job. Shouldn't be so hard.
3. It gives me another reason go watch the copy of The Ruby in the Smoke that's been kicking around my house for ages, which is pretty much his most notable movie role. He did also do The History Boys on stage, so he's presumably got some acting chops.
4. Smith is young. Which would presumably mean he's pretty eager, and hopefully will appreciate this big break and not be itching to go off to the next thing after a season or two. It takes me so long to adjust to the change, that I'd like the Doctors to stick around for a while longer.
5. Maybe this means they can get a big name to be his new companion? I don't know for sure, but I'm guessing that a newcomer like Matt Smith comes slightly cheaper than the now in-demand David Tennant or someone like Christopher Eccleston. So perhaps they can spend extra cash wooing someone awesome to travel around with the Doctor. I can think of dozens of people who would be amazing. And if the fans don't like the new Doctor being someone so young, they could also cast someone "older and wiser" to go on this journey with him. Win-win.
6. Age is just a state of mind. And in the Doctor's case, it's sort of just a state of something else entirely. I mean, does it matter if the outer shell of this guy is young? He may look like a 26-year-old on the outside, but he's still the same doctor that has lived for hundreds of years and has seen everything. As long as Smith can step it up in the acting department and handle all of the heaviness and humor that goes with being the Time Lord, who really cares what he looks like? Besides, if I were going to regenerate myself, I'd want to be a younger version too.
Your thoughts on the new guy? Leave 'em below.
8 Comments
Add a comment
Search thousands of recaps and more
BLOG ARCHIVES
The Telefile
January 2010
34 Entries
December 2009
32 Entries
November 2009
47 Entries
October 2009
65 Entries
September 2009
66 Entries
August 2009
58 Entries
July 2009
72 Entries
June 2009
71 Entries
May 2009
50 Entries
April 2009
57 Entries
March 2009
66 Entries
February 2009
52 Entries
January 2009
56 Entries
December 2008
51 Entries
November 2008
71 Entries
October 2008
88 Entries
September 2008
86 Entries
August 2008
120 Entries
July 2008
115 Entries
June 2008
90 Entries
May 2008
44 Entries
April 2008
30 Entries
March 2008
27 Entries
February 2008
30 Entries
January 2008
44 Entries
December 2007
31 Entries
November 2007
66 Entries
Blog Categories
A Guest Star is Born
7 Entries
Annals Of Fantasy Stuntcasting
27 Entries
Annals Of Stuntcasting
79 Entries
Around The Rest Of The Media
29 Entries
Awards
33 Entries
Can't They Just Leave Well Enough Alone?
51 Entries
Celebrity Child Abuse
10 Entries
Character Corner
78 Entries
Commercials In Antiquity
3 Entries
Cool Stuff We Need
9 Entries
Crossover Alert!
2 Entries
Dear Sir Or Madam: No One Cares
15 Entries
DVDs Unwrapped
4 Entries
Everybody Dance Now
25 Entries
Everything's Better With Music
47 Entries
Fall TV
5 Entries
Follies Of The Overrated
33 Entries
Good Things Come In Small Packages?
25 Entries
Great Moments In Real TV
66 Entries
Helpful Hints And Site Business
9 Entries
Hollywood Self-Congratulation Corner
9 Entries
Hollywood To TWoP: Hello There!
104 Entries
I Hate Procedurals
5 Entries
IMDb Fun Times
2 Entries
Irrational Exuberance
192 Entries
Judging Fictional Strangers
65 Entries
Judging Strangers
151 Entries
Less Famous Siblings
8 Entries
Let's Go to the Video
137 Entries
Let's Review, Shall We?
24 Entries
Lying Liars Who Lie
4 Entries
Not Available on Laserdisc
3 Entries
Not Just Super, It's Supernatural
2 Entries
Notes and Comment
22 Entries
Obituaries Without Pity
14 Entries
Olympics
26 Entries
PBS: It's Good For You
6 Entries
Picks
7 Entries
Producers Speak Out
11 Entries
Reading: It's Fundamental
1 Entries
Really Ridiculous Reality Shows
114 Entries
Shameless Acts of TWoP Self-Promotion
15 Entries
Show vs. Show
6 Entries
Shows Nobody Cares About Anymore Except Us
39 Entries
Skimming Across the Pond
21 Entries
Soap Auditions
10 Entries
Stars Making News
67 Entries
That's F&*!ed Up
101 Entries
The Biz
134 Entries
The Forgotten
7 Entries
The TCAs
6 Entries
The Upfronts: First Looks
7 Entries
Things We Can't Stop Saying
4 Entries
Things We're Ashamed Of
5 Entries
Today's TWoP News
214 Entries
Top of the TWoP
5 Entries
True Confessions
5 Entries
True Tales Of The TWoP Bullpen
10 Entries
Tubey Awards
13 Entries
TV on DVD
21 Entries
TWoP 10
82 Entries
TWoP On The Town
4 Entries
TWoP To The Rescue
18 Entries
Vagaries Of Scheduling
13 Entries
Very Bad Things
39 Entries
We Ask, They Answer
6 Entries
We Got Sports, How 'Bout You?
27 Entries
We Should Totally Be TV Execs
16 Entries
Were We Ever So Young?
8 Entries
WGA Strike
32 Entries
He's too young unless they want to rename the series Intern Who.
I've just recently gotten into Doctor Who (yeah, I know. What the hell was I thinking waiting this long?!), but I'm willing to give Matt a chance. For all the reasons Angel gave. Although now I must go Netflix Ruby in the Smoke...
I was initially apprehensive but I recently rewatched the first series and it reminded me. I loved Christopher Eccleston and though I was heartbroken when he left, I quickly grew to love Tennant's Doctor, so I am willing to give Matt Smith a chance.
I've been going back and forth, too. I watched the interview with him and he seemed very charming, which made me optimistic because charming is one of the number one things I look for in a doctor. I still feel like he might have made a better companion, but I'm willing to trust that Stephen Moffat knows what he's doing, and I'm getting really excited about seeing Matt Smith take over.
I'm kind of open to anyone since I was one of the ones unsure when Tennant came who now wishes he was staying. (Actually, I'm more heartbroken that Catherine Tate left.) But I must be getting really old because a) he does not look 26 to me; and b) my first thought at that picture was "What's with the Flock of Seagulls haircut?"
"And if the fans don't like the new Doctor being someone so young, they could also cast someone "older and wiser" to go on this journey with him."
Well, the Doctor is still going to be 900+ years old. He's just going to look like he's in his 20s.
But still, I think an older companion is probably the best way to go.
At first I was apprehensive, but after watching the BBC's Doctor Who Confidential that revealed the pick, I think he'll be just fine. I'm actually more interested to know how the 11th Doctor comes to be. With all the excitement of a surprise regeneration gone, I'm hoping the introduction is a bit different. Maybe he leaves the 10th Doctor and comes back the 11th in just a few seconds of our time, but years later in his time.
Let's face it, we all just want to know what outfit Eleven is going to be wearing....