BLOGS

TWoP 10: Things We're Dreading About This Season of American Idol

We were so glad to have the local audition and Hollywood Week nonsense finally behind us, but now that we're into the actual performance and voting portion of American Idol, we have to say that we've never been less inclined to pick up the phone for someone as we are this year. For all of the "most talented group ever" hype, we've yet to hear anything that remotely lives up to it. Instead, we've got a dull mess of kids, Ellen trying desperately to be relevant and Simon looking like he's just counting the minutes until X-Factor begins. It's going to be a long season, and here's what we're dreading the most:

10. Todrick Hall's R&B Versions of Everything
While we're grateful that Tyler is gone early and we aren't going to be subjected to his impressions of Jim Morrison and his floppy Sanjaya hair for the rest of the season, we'd have been happier if he took Todrick and his random R&B versions of songs along with him. There's just something about a guy who sings a song about himself and then ruins Kelly Clarkson that rubs us the wrong way.

9. The Inevitable Overruns
Four judges is clearly too many, especially when three of them are basically just little clones saying the same thing over and over in slightly different ways. With all these opinions, we're sure that the show will run long on more than one occasion this season (if not every single week). On the plus side, we're not sure we care enough about any of these contestants to be annoyed if our DVRs don't record them.

8. Old Idol Wannabes Returning
There is nothing worse than a results show, except results shows that likely will feature ex-contestants like the now tragically blonde Katharine McPhee singing. We dread seeing the former also-rans (and sometimes winners) even more than the pre-recorded performances by pop artists, though it's a close call.

7. Recurring Kara/Casey Sex Jokes
We get it that Kara thinks Casey is hot (though we're not entirely sure why) and his taking his shirt off was a cute gimmick, but this needs to stop. Not only does the entire judging panel turn into a blubbering, unintelligible mess of goo every time he opens his mouth, but they then think their jokes about Kara's obvious crush are so funny. Enough. Let it go. Especially you, Randy.

6. Michael Lynche's Baby Talk
Every season, the editors make us hate an otherwise perfectly fine contestant by jamming one fact about their personal lives down our throats so much that we basically can't help but want to see them gone as soon as possible. Last year, it was Danny Gokey and his dead wife. This year that dishonor goes to Michael Lynche and his ongoing baby story. Oh God, when they inevitably visit his hometown and we see him with the baby? We're cringing already.

5. Repeated Criticism of Song Choices
Well, it's not just Simon who's excited for X-Factor. We are, too, since those judges actually act as advisers to their contestants instead of just sitting behind a table criticizing their "song choice" after the fact (that phrase rapidly becoming our two most hated words in the English language) without giving them any real, constructive guidance on what they should do instead. Which brings us to...

4. The Bipolar Judges
"Change it up." "No, don't change it up, you ruined it!" "You need to make it yours!" "That didn't sound enough like the original." "You've got to break out of the box like David Cook!" "No, that was only cool when Adam Lambert did it." Seriously, the mixed messages are getting old. And if a song stinks because someone just can't sing very well, then say that. And while they're at it, the judges should own up to the fact that they're the ones that put these people through in the first place.

3. Justin Bieber/Jo Bro Fans Keeping Tim and Aaron Around
These two contestants are straight out of the pages of Lisa Simpson's Non-Threatening Boys Magazine. Tim Urban's got the cute backstory about getting a second shot and he tried to be polite while Simon told him he sucked, while Aaron Kelly is totally the new Archuleta and/or Chicken Little.

2. Anything at All Involving Lilly Scott.
Have we ever hated a contestant more based on sight alone? Hard to say, but she's definitely up there. There's just so much that's disingenuous about her that her purposely dyed-granny hair and comically oversized treble clef tattoo pushes her -- or rather us -- over the edge.

1. Ellen Trying to Find New Ways to Say She Doesn't Know Anything About Musical Technique
We'll give it to Ellen: she was amusing when taunting the contestants during the Hollywood Week results episodes. But now that the show is live, we're pretty much over her. The "I don't know nothin' 'bout birthin' no Billboard songs, but I know what I like" response becomes more and more useless each time she gives it. As are the comments about people having nice hair and being cute and getting votes. Those really aren't useful criticisms, and with Randy and Kara only sometimes contributing anything remotely valuable, we're now questioning the decision to hire "E" more than ever.

Honorable Mentions
We're also not looking forward to seeing Alex (not Adam!) Lambert's mullet; Haeley Vaughn's forthcoming televised meltdown after she realizes she isn't as good as she thinks she is (actually, we are sort of looking forward to that); and the gradual beautification of Crystal (complete with personality strip-mining) so she can appeal to more viewers. The teeth-whitening has already started, so you know full dreadlock removal and robotic responses during Ryan's interviews can't be far behind. Too bad.

30 Comments

February 26, 2010 10:45 AM
Amy
Reply

I really agree with 4 and 5. I was just thinking how bad that got on my nerves, that the judges tell one contestant that they need to "take a risk" and "try something out of the box", but anytime anyone does, they "destroyed the song" I wish they would at least suggest what they should sing--the only time I saw that happen was with Crystal, when Simon suggested singing David Bowie.

February 26, 2010 10:48 AM
buddy faggot
Reply

Bullshit! Ellen is amazing

February 26, 2010 12:33 PM
Ellen (not that one)
Reply

This probably wasn't the intention for hiring Ellen, but I don't see a problem with a music enthusiast being part of the judging panel. I think it's safe to say the majority of the viewing population also knows little to nothing about musical technique, yet we are the ones who will be buying the records and supporting the artists. It doesn't matter how many critics praise the technical merit of a singer I don't like -- it's not going to convince me that they're any good. So Ellen can just go on with her bad self...

February 26, 2010 12:36 PM
Vivian
Reply

I totally agree with everything except #8. I really, really love seeing the alums return. Oftentimes, they show the newbies how it's done, and I just enjoy seeing old favorites again.

February 26, 2010 12:55 PM
TheHellYouSay
Reply

I'm firmly against polishing up Crystal. I love her all grungy and Deadhead road ratty -- reminds me of my own misspent youth.

February 26, 2010 12:59 PM
red rabbit
Reply

Ellen has turned out to be one of the best things about this show. She may not know music technique but she has a lot of performance knowledge and, contrary to Kara and Randy and Paula (good riddance), she has 1) a sizeable vocabulary and 2) speaks in complete sentences. It's nice to have an intelligent person on the panel for once.

February 26, 2010 2:33 PM
Paolo
Reply

Love Lilly Scott. She's got a great voice and I'm rooting for her because of that. I like Ellen too, she's not a Simon, but she's definitely better than Kara and Randy and Paula, so this list is, for me for you for me, utter bullshit.

February 26, 2010 3:21 PM
Jennifer
Reply
replied to comment from Ellen (not that one)

But why do we need one of us on the panel? Don't we do our judging by voting? I want clear, coherent music criticism from the judges - not 'hey, I just love music like you guys watching'. (I know, I'm watching the wrong show, but still . . .)

February 26, 2010 3:38 PM
Elizabeth
Reply

I was slightly excited about Ellen during Hollywood Week, but seriously, she needs to start listening instead of just commenting on peole's looks. All she did was give the Justin Beiberish contestants props for their -cough- cuteness. Ew.

February 26, 2010 3:47 PM
hazel
Reply

Randy, Kara, and Simon have loads of experience in various aspects of the music industry and yet, they rarely give advice that is constructive or useful. At least Ellen has an excuse. Although, at least in theory, she should be able to give the contestants some very helpful advice on performance and what it takes to project confidence on stage or tips on how to get their nerves under control. I don't mind Ellen as a judge, but I still think four judges is too many. Especially when the comments are mostly useless.

February 26, 2010 4:34 PM
ma
Reply

Disagree with #8. Idols should come back -- so many have grown since their season.

Katharine has done alot more than you give her credit for-----actually she is one idol contestant who has had alot of success beyond Idol! So I STRONGLY disagree about your above comment concerning Katharine!!!!

February 26, 2010 4:54 PM
Ottis
Reply

They have rarely been honest about the importance of good looks on AI (Simon has tried a few times with a "You don't look like a rock star" or "This isn't for you"), but that's what the initial Hollywood rounds are about. Get rid of the ugly people. And most of the fat people, unless they are fat/adorable like Reuben or Big Mike.I wish they would own up to it and then stop the hair and other looks comments.

February 26, 2010 5:45 PM
Jonathan
Reply

It's a shame they probably won't bring Howard Stern onto the judging panel. He would inject some much-needed "reality" to the panel. And boy, oh, boy - Simon is so bored this season. He just can't wait to leave, and it may just make this season the first one that I stop watching. BTW - PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE get rid of Kara Dio-whateverherface. Yes, Paula was wacky, but Kara trying to "play" with Simon is so fake and stupid, and Paula should have gotten every cent Kara makes on the show. Unless they really shake things up, Idol won't last a season once X-Factor starts up. And please - enough with the "Idol Cares" stuff. Just donate all that dough and leave us out of it.

February 26, 2010 5:57 PM
Judy Delamotte
Reply

Why why why id they ever think Ellen would be good for that program???????? She looks and acts like an "idot" just sittting thier trying to act like she knows something. She;s OK on her talk show but on American Idol.....Why do they even need her. I like the 3 judges who know what they are talking about. Why not just have a guest judge instead of having Ellen. She acts so stupid. It's hard to watch her. get her out or the show will tank. Judy

February 26, 2010 7:18 PM
COCO
Reply

Why is it that you us "we" in all these articles? Just the who the fuck are you talking for? Because you surely aren't talking for me, and if you actually read the Idol forum you'd realize that a lot of people like Ellen.

And I'm sure they aren't in lock step with a lot of your other comments either.

So unless you are royalty...STFU with the "we" shit.

February 26, 2010 9:10 PM
WicktSmaht
Reply

I totally agree with the comment on Simon. He was annoying me Wednesday night when he wouldn't look up at the contestant (I think it was Andy) at the end of the night. If you are going to tell people to suck it up and be professional, you should set that example by being professional yourself. As for Ellen - I have mixed feelings, but I will say that comedy and the music business are, in some ways, similar, and she can lend some of her expertise from her experience in that area.

February 26, 2010 10:17 PM
bruton gaster
Reply
replied to comment from COCO

Hey COCO, the 'we' is referring to the TWOP staffers. They don't try to speak for us, don't worry.

February 27, 2010 1:13 AM
joe
Reply

Hiring Ellen Degeneres is mind-boggling. Anyone who served as a guest judge during auditions would've been better than she is: Shania Twain, Katy Perry, NPH (that would've been LEGENDARY), and even Avril Lavigne and Posh Spice. The problem, I guess, is that these folks are busy with shit to do, while Ellen apparently isn't so busy with her daytime show. But seriously, can you imagine someone like Katy Perry or NPH contributing actual musical material while having the spine to disagree with Simon & Co.? A horrible, horrible hire.

February 27, 2010 3:40 AM
Andy Bluebear
Reply

I think Ellen is fine. Give her time, she just started. NPH would be doing the same if he was a judge. She's still getting used to the live shows, so it's still early to judge her so harshly. For the record, I'll take her as a judge over Randy any day. And Katy Perry is just annoying, so hiring her would just be 'ew'.

February 27, 2010 7:49 AM
Marina
Reply

So agree about "E". I was a total skeptic at first, but then Hollywood Week swayed me over with the funny. But now? Sheesh, I just wish she'd stop talking. I don't mind her "I'm one of the people and the people will vote for you" comments - but does she really need to say the exact same thing FIVE times in the space of 30 seconds?! "Yeah, you'll get votes because you're adorable and you know you're adorable but you need to be more than adorable but that doesn't really matter because you're adorable and you'll get votes but you could try singing a bit better as well being adorable and maybe you'll get more votes but the fact that you're adorable will get you votes anyway" ... WTF?! I cannot stand an entire season of that.

February 27, 2010 10:30 AM
Sausalito
Reply
replied to comment from Marina

Marina, that's just Ellen's shtick. She repeats herself over and over in a deadpan and self-depracating tone and never finishes the sentence because she keeps looping around to the start again and repeating the same words in slightly different, but actually also quite similar, ways.

February 27, 2010 8:58 PM
E
Reply

I was watching old idol performances and I have to say right now--I miss Paula! She was goofy, yes, but there was a warmth to her and unpredictability that I miss already. I love Ellen...but not on this show.

March 1, 2010 1:46 AM
Sarah
Reply

Awww, I love Lilly Scott. I even like her hair, which I enjoy looking at much more than that over-curled, unruly mop on the top of Katelyn Epperly's head.

March 12, 2010 3:41 PM
Adam
Reply

I'd like to add:
11. Randy booing every time Simon is introduced. He's been doing every show for the past few seasons. Enough already.

March 13, 2010 6:03 PM
Rick
Reply

I've really been disappointed with this year's crop of "talent" and when I watched the return of Scott and Matt on Thursday, it really solidified my opinion. Those 2 "also-rans" have so much more talent and personality than any of this year's bunch. What a shame.

March 14, 2010 2:41 PM
Carolyn
Reply

I disagree with some, agree with others. You're definitely missing my biggest annoyance of Idol this season, Randy. He needs to be numero uno. Terrible comments, barely anything constructive, and he's just plain annoying with the use of the word "dog", his booing of Simon and his random exertion of unnecessary words when it's not even his turn to talk. And how could you call Lilly Scott "disingenuous"? She has a great voice and brought a whole new range to the show. Kara was right when she said that everything about her was "refreshing". So sad to see her go this week :(

March 14, 2010 11:06 PM
Serious Sam
Reply

Angel Cohn is the thing that not relevant. Change it up, guys.

March 20, 2010 1:36 AM
freetress synthetic braiding hair
Reply

lol, I adore Alisha Hair

August 25, 2011 1:49 AM
bathroom vanity cabinets
Reply

This web site does not show up correctly on my apple iphone - you may wanna try and repair that

March 14, 2012 1:00 AM
sex
Reply

lütfen söylediğim müziklerini dinleyin saygılar

Loading...

Add a comment

TWoP Toolbar

BLOG ARCHIVES

The Telefile

April 2012

38 Entries

March 2012

68 Entries

February 2012

64 Entries

January 2012

78 Entries

December 2011

49 Entries

November 2011

56 Entries

October 2011

74 Entries

September 2011

78 Entries

August 2011

61 Entries

July 2011

56 Entries

June 2011

57 Entries

May 2011

57 Entries

April 2011

78 Entries

March 2011

73 Entries

February 2011

57 Entries

January 2011

65 Entries

December 2010

39 Entries

November 2010

45 Entries

October 2010

46 Entries

September 2010

62 Entries

August 2010

55 Entries

July 2010

53 Entries

June 2010

65 Entries

May 2010

59 Entries

April 2010

57 Entries

March 2010

67 Entries

February 2010

53 Entries

January 2010

59 Entries

December 2009

32 Entries

November 2009

47 Entries

October 2009

65 Entries

September 2009

66 Entries

August 2009

58 Entries

July 2009

72 Entries

June 2009

71 Entries

May 2009

50 Entries

April 2009

57 Entries

March 2009

66 Entries

February 2009

52 Entries

January 2009

56 Entries

December 2008

51 Entries

November 2008

71 Entries

October 2008

88 Entries

September 2008

86 Entries

August 2008

120 Entries

July 2008

115 Entries

June 2008

90 Entries

May 2008

44 Entries

April 2008

30 Entries

March 2008

26 Entries

February 2008

30 Entries

January 2008

44 Entries

December 2007

31 Entries

November 2007

66 Entries