BLOGS

Pilot Season: A Guide to What We May (or May Not) Want to See This Fall

Lately, the news has been filled with reports of pilot episodes for new series getting ordered by all of the major networks, not to mention basic and premium cable channels. And while it's presumptuous to form opinions about them based on little more than a one-sentence description, once you factor in casting news and who the writer and director are, you start to get a pretty good idea of what to expect. Not counting shows still in the scripting stage, or shows that already have a series commitment, here are some of the best- and worst-sounding pilots being developed -- although since they get added and dropped frequently, this may not be fully accurate for long. (Generic-sounding romantic comedies and family dramas get a bye this round, because it's hard to muster strong feelings about them, but we'll revisit them if and when they make it to series.)

The Best-Sounding Pilots:

House of Lies (Showtime)
A Showtime series that doesn't center around a sarcastic white woman? We're in! Don Cheadle will star as a morally flexible management consultant, and Kristen Bell will play an associate at his firm. War Machine in a series, and Veronica Mars back on TV? This sounds like a dream come true. Plus, the director also did the pilots for The Unusuals and Californication, so it might be pretty good.

Little in Common (Fox)
A sitcom about three families who connect through Little League sports may not sound like the next Modern Family, but we'll check it out because it's from the mind of Veronica Mars and Party Down creator Rob Thomas. (Clearly, we're fans.)

Temp (NBC)
Speaking of Veronica Mars and Party Down, Rob Thomas and his co-writers also came up with this pilot, about people who change jobs every week, shortly after they found out their cult series about cater-waiters had been cancelled.

Awakening (The CW)
With The Walking Dead somewhat of a disappointing mess so far, a dumbed-down CW version, about coming-of-age sisters facing off against each other during a zombie uprising, might be just what the doctor ordered. We're especially curious to see how one of them can be both "coming of age" and a public defender. Is she a teen lawyer?

Ringer (CBS)
As happy as we are to have Kristen Bell back on our TV (and hopefully cutting back on big-screen romantic comedies), we're equally happy to have Sarah Michelle Gellar back, playing a woman on the run from the mob who pretends to be her wealthy twin sister. While the premise sounds a little goofy, it's SMG -- possibly two SMGs! Now no more Scooby-Doo.

Poe (NBC)
A crime procedural set in 1840's Boston? With Edgar Allan Poe as lead detective? We are so there, if only to see if it turns out to be a train wreck.

Grace (ABC)
With former Fly Girl (and Dancing With the Stars judge) Carrie Ann Inaba producing, we can at least expect some great dancing in this drama series about a dysfunctional family of professional dancers.

Alcatraz (Fox)
J.J. Abrams is behind yet another series set on a mystical island starring Hugo Reyes, and this time it's one you may have been to. The series is about convicts who vanished from Alcatraz when it was a prison and then turn up in the modern day, and while J.J. may eventually get bored and walk away from it, allowing it to run into the ground, the pilot episode should be fantastic.

Hart of Dixie (The CW)
The plot may sound familiar, but we'll tune into this show about a New York City doctor setting up practice in an oddball Southern town because it's produced by Josh Schwartz. We're picturing a hot Northern Exposure, and we like it.

Playboy (NBC)
NBC was smart to get Alan Taylor -- who directed five episodes of Mad Men, including the Emmy-nominated pilot -- to direct their pilot about a Playboy club in 1960s Chicago. It's practically a Mad Men spin-off at this point already, which means we're at least curious to check it out.

As the Story Develops (HBO)
Keith Olbermann was rumored to be involved in this Aaron Sorkin series about a cable news show, but his talk show (and Chris Matthews') apparently only provided the inspiration. While Sorkin's record with TV shows about TV shows is 50-50, the rest of his work (including Social Network) speaks for itself, usually very quickly and while walking.

Dallas (TNT)
This reboot of the 1980's soap will bring back original cast members Larry Hagman, Patrick Duffy and Linda Gray, but it will also follow the next generation of the tumultuous Ewing family. Jordana Brewster will play the cook's daughter, Elena, who's torn between two Ewing cousins. It's like Vampire Diaries without the vampires!

Exit Strategy (Fox)
Ethan Hawke will re-team with director Antoine Fuqua (Training Day, Brooklyn's Finest) for this pilot about a CIA extraction team who get their fellow agents out of bad situations in real time, a la 24. Each episode will take place in a different country. Watching Ethan Hawke try to be Jack Bauer should be... interesting.

Smash (NBC)
A musical. About the staging of a Broadway show. Developed by Steven Spielberg. Originally for Showtime. While it will surely lose some of its initial edge on a broadcast network, any musical supplement/alternative to Glee is all right by us.

Cooper and Stone (The CW)
Two young, female detectives in Chicago who discuss clothes, fashion, pop culture and solve homicides? It sounds like a (slightly) younger Rizzoli & Isles, which isn't anything we were particularly looking for, but the involvement of one of the producers of Life has us intrigued.

Untitled Shonda Rhimes Fixer Show (ABC)
There are a lot of factors left to be seen in this show about a crisis manager, based on the real-life woman who handled the Monica Lewinsky and Chandra Levy scandals, but it's Shonda Rhimes, who gave us Grey's, and the pilot will be directed by Paul McGuigan, who recently did the pilot episode of Sherlock.

Rookies (CBS)
We can't help thinking of last year's failed awful rookie-cop drama Rookie Blue, but this show about six rookies balancing their work and personal lives is set in NYC, written by a writer from The Wire, and produced by Robert De Niro. "Could be good" is an understatement.

17th Precinct (NBC)
Battlestar Galactica producer Ron Moore is behind this cop drama, which takes place in a world where magic is used in place of science. Set in a town called Excelsior (Stan Lee cameo, anyone?), it's being described as an adult Harry Potter, but we'll settle for Cast a Deadly Spell: The Series.

The Wedding Band (TBS)
Melora Hardin (The Office) plays an events company president who hires two lifelong friends (Brian Austin Green and Peter Cambor) and their band to play all of her events. We don't watch many TBS shows, but we're behind whatever gets the Notorious B.A.G. off of Desperate Housewives and Cambor off of NCIS: Los Angeles.

Locke & Key (Fox)
Based on an acclaimed comic book, the family of a murdered man moves into his ancestral, very creepy home, where an evil entity threatens to possess them all. Hooray, scary TV shows!

The River (Fox)
Speaking of scary, a journey up the Amazon river to find a missing family member, written by the writers of Paranormal Activity? Color us intrigued.

The Worst-Sounding Pilots:

Pan Am (ABC)
Another series perhaps looking to trade on Mad Men's acclaim, this "sexy soap" will follow Pan Am pilots and stewardesses in the 1960's, when the airline was an industry leader. We're sure it's nothing like that other airline show The Loop, but who wants to spend that much time on a plane? And it's ABC, so even the prospect of people joining the Mile High Club can only disappoint.

Touch (Fox)
After Heroes, we're going to have trouble trusting Tim Kring again. Especially not when his new show is about a mute-autistic kid who can predict the future. The sad part? The pilot is probably going to be really, really good. But we won't be fooled again.

Heavenly (The CW)
As much as we love Castiel on Supernatural, we've been burned by one too many remakes of Wings of Desire and two too many versions of Cupid to have any interest in a show about a young female attorney who teams up with a former angel to save her clients' souls.

Charlie's Angels (ABC)
We'll admit that the movies were occasionally fun, but the casting of the three high-kicking girls in this reboot isn't grabbing us, with one exception. One's a soap star, one's that annoying hacker girl from the first Transformers and one's Minka Kelly (yep, the exception). We remember how Bionic Woman worked out, and we're nervous.

Family Album (Fox)
If the entire season follows an extended family on vacation, the pilot episode should get as far as, what, the airport? We'd rather wait for another Modern Family vacation episode. With the writers of Perfect Couples doing the writing and Shawn Levy (Date Night) doing the directing, we may never reach the hotel.

Wonder Woman (NBC)
We still don't understand why David E. Kelley is anywhere near this thing. Looking at Harry's Law, and then reading that Kelley's Wonder Woman is a successful corporate executive as well as a vigilante, we can't see how this could be any good. And McG directing the pilot? We know he did the pilot for Chuck, but this is a different story.

Partners (ABC)
Police detectives who are secretly sisters? So they're fiercely loyal to each other? That sounds pretty ridiculous, and it will only seem more so once the pilot is directed by the man who did the pilot for V.

Grimm (NBC)
We're willing to accept a police station in a land of magic, but a cop drama where the cops investigate Grimm's fairy tales? A little too precious for us. After all, there's no way it could be as good as the comic book Fables, even with Angel co-creator David Greenwalt and writer Jim Louf involved.

The Finder (Fox)
We aren't ones to say what Bones fans will or won't like, but this spin-off about a man who can "find anything," based on the Locator books, sounds kind of dull. And the star, Geoff Stults, hasn't had a great track record when it comes to his choice of shows.

Work It (ABC)
Two men cross-dressing as women to get jobs as pharmaceutical reps? What is this, 1982?

Are You There Vodka? It's Me, Chelsea (NBC)
Inspired by Chelsea Handler's autobiography, this comedy is being written by the co-creators of Dharma & Greg, and might be a little bit too much for us to handle. Just like the title.

Big Mike (A&E)
We couldn't stand watching Greg Grunberg play a cop on Heroes, so we aren't sure we'll be able to sit through an entire episode, let alone a season, of him as a police detective.

Hallelujah (ABC)
A Marc Cherry joint, the pilot finds the forces of good and evil tearing apart the town of Hallelujah, Tennessee. How could anything be more evil than Teri Hatcher on Desperate Housewives?

Brave New World (NBC)
Peter Tolan has a good track record, most recently on Rescue Me, but we'll wait and see on this comedy, which follows the historically re-enacting employees of theme park Pilgrim Village. We can see a movie about the subject, but an entire series set there?

Once Upon a Time (ABC)
Another story about fairy tales that are real? Set in Maine? Written by the guys who wrote Tron: Legacy? So it'll be a long, boring version of Haven?

Revenge (ABC)
A modern-day Count of Monte Cristo, written by the guy who did Swingtown and set in the Hamptons. We're already getting kind of sleepy.

Happily Divorced (TV Land)
In the continuing TV Land tradition of hiring long-forgotten former TV stars to star in new shows, Fran Drescher will play a woman starting life anew after finding out her husband is gay. We would call it preposterous, if it wasn't based on her actual life. And while we like Drescher as a pop cultural touchstone, we aren't sure we like her as an actress on our televisions.

Good Christian Bitches (ABC)
Described as "Desperate Housewives in Dallas," our question is: why, exactly?

What do you think of these pilots? Any sound good? Any sound awful? Agree? Disagree? Do share!

What are people saying about your favorite shows and stars right now? Find out with Talk Without Pity, the social media site for real TV fans. See Tweets and Facebook comments in real time and add your own -- all without leaving TWoP. Join the conversation now!

28 Comments

February 1, 2011 6:55 PM
Amanda
Reply

There's clearly a glaring omission here: if Switched at Birth on ABC Family does NOT turn out to be the worst show I've ever seen, I'll be absolutely shocked.

February 1, 2011 7:11 PM
JB
Reply

Both Kristen Bell and Sarah Michelle Gelllar back on TV? I need to sit down, I'm feeling faint.

February 1, 2011 9:13 PM
Nemesis
Reply

So, I have one more reason to hate "Mad Men." Thanks to that steaming pile, all asshole writers have to do these days is trot out a show set in the not-too-distant past, treat the women on it like crap, then claim it's all just due to "the times" they're depicting. Great way to avoid taking responsibility for filling the airwaves with sexist bullshit, I guess.

February 1, 2011 11:49 PM
Sawyer
Reply
replied to comment from Nemesis

Mad Men is sexist? You've never actually watched the show, have you?

February 2, 2011 6:03 AM
Fab
Reply

Wait, despite being ABC's most successful Summer show debut in almost six years and already being renewed for a second season after three episodes, you say Rookie Blue was a failure? Alright then. Thanks for playing.

February 2, 2011 7:52 AM
tahjmer
Reply
replied to comment from Nemesis

Yeah, going back to the sixties is going to be overplayed and will become really sad. With that said, Mad Men is as sexist as it is racist, classist, smoker-friendly, and hard on non-"manly" men simply because it is showing a time directly before steadily enforced civil rights acts, bra-burning, hardcore anti-smoking campaigns and distain over the status quo. Hopefully with later seasons we will see more evidence of how time changed people and their views on women.

February 2, 2011 9:51 AM
Leah
Reply
replied to comment from Fab

That's exactly what I was going to say. Just because you didn't like the show doesn't mean it failed. Nice try.

Also, how is the remake of Dallas going to be exactly like The Vampire Diaries without vampires? Because they're both teen dramas?I'm confused.

February 2, 2011 9:52 AM
A.
Reply

I think watching how simple air travel used to be on that Pan Am show is going to be so frustrating that people will throw things at their TVs...

February 2, 2011 10:01 AM
Sammo
Reply
replied to comment from Leah

I think the comparison comes from both shows having a character named Elena choosing between two hot guys. One show with vampires. One without. Does that help?

February 2, 2011 10:15 AM
HoneyBee
Reply

I'm excited to see these Rob Thomas' shows... and Kristen Bell's new show.

February 2, 2011 10:49 AM
Jason/Lantern7
Reply

Not much to say at the moment. Since when is Susan Meyer evil? I jumped off the DW wagon a few years ago, and she would be the last housewife to go dark side.

I think the biggest lesson from the summaries is this: read Fables. Good stuff from Bill Willingham.

February 2, 2011 11:40 AM
Pinky
Reply

Do the writers of Paranormal Activity have any writing experience?

February 2, 2011 11:45 AM
Kristen
Reply

Poe sounds great, but also expensive and therefore cancellation fodder. I'll watch anyway, even though they'll break my heart. I'll check out Exit Strategy since I missed the whole 24 bandwagon. And Alcatraz since I missed the whole Lost bandwagon.

The Wedding Band looks stupid. Really stupid. And I'm not gonna lie: Grimm sounds awesome. You know it does.

February 2, 2011 11:46 AM
Patrick
Reply

A Locke & Key television show!?! AWESOME!!
Oh, wait. It's going to be on Fox? Well, I guess I'll enjoy it while it lasts. [sigh]

February 2, 2011 12:16 PM
w
Reply

I

February 2, 2011 12:18 PM
KB
Reply

Re: The Awakening, first of all, The Walking Dead is kind of awesome. Second of all, how can a dumbed down version be better unless you're actually dumb?

February 2, 2011 1:26 PM
Uncle Igmar
Reply
replied to comment from Nemesis

Ahhh - nothing like looking at the 1960's through the glasses modern sensibilities.

While I totally agree that even one more show about the 1960's is not needed - calling the writers, creators or anyone else involved with Mad Men "sexist" is simply moronic.

The issues depicted in Mad Men were things that actually went on in the 60's and yes - even to those of us who lived back then, they are shocking when looked at by today's standards, but they happened - so live with it.

February 2, 2011 2:07 PM
Chrissy
Reply

Who said Walking Dead is disappointing mess? It got a globe nomination after only 6 episodes. The writer is way off with that remark.

February 2, 2011 3:31 PM
Lauren
Reply
replied to comment from Fab

I had the same thought when I read that line. I actually loved Rookie Blue, and apparently, so did the public (or at least the ones with Nielsen boxes and/or DVRs).

February 2, 2011 3:40 PM
zelmia
Reply

Weird. I had an idea for a Poe-based TV show back in my film school days. Of course mine was quite a different take on the character and would have incorporated his actual writings. But I also thought at the time that it would have too esoteric for TV. I think I still do.

February 2, 2011 3:44 PM
lacey
Reply

Ringer is the only show that piques my interest and that's because I'm excited SMG is back on tv. Some of these pilots sound so horrible it's as if the people thinking up the concepts were drunk.

February 2, 2011 4:00 PM
Leah
Reply
replied to comment from Sammo

Yes it does, thanks. I still don't see how that's really relevant, but it makes a lot more sense now.

February 2, 2011 4:19 PM
Sara
Reply

Nothing about Showtime's Homeland with Claire Danes and Damian Lewis? That's the one I most hope gets ordered to series.

February 2, 2011 5:02 PM
JJSmith
Reply

Now you have Tim Kring sticker shock? I'm still recovering from JAYbrams sticker shock, though I sympathize about the possibilities of the "Touch" pilot. So, everyone thinks fairy tales are this year's vampires? What's up with that. Also, why are you giving JJ a pass again? He's proved himself to be a competent feature director and a good idea man, but his attention span is WOEFULLY short for a showrunner. Kring at least buys the medium and Heroes might not have been such a disaster in follow-up seasons absent the strike.

I'm pulling for House of Lies because I love Kristen Bell and she desperately needs a hit. It's not so much that she did a string of romantic comedies. She did a string of BAD romantic comedies. Now she and her fans have to recover from it.

I'm hoping Rob Thomas has a full-on hit with Temp because he's been awesome for a long time without one, but this doesn't sound like the end of his writing spectrum that I enjoy.

I'm guarded but hopeful on The Ringer.

Poe--this sounds like a nightmare cross of Sleepy Hollow (the Burton version) and Peacemakers (take the crime procedural to a different time period). Plus, are they really going to try to make a hero out of Poe? Yikes! Historically accurate, he'd come off as a depressive monster and dressed up as a tragic hero he'd come off like a "name" they're trying (and failing) to be cute with.

You folks take really vicious swipes at Studio 60, and frankly, I don't think it's warranted. It was a solid, interesting show that was cancelled far too soon. As The Story Develops might have some potential.

Cooper and Stone will have to depend on casting (a chancy thing at the CW) but the Life pedigree does provide some hope. Rizzoli and Isles is just fine as a summer series.

17th Precinct sounds like it has possibilities, but why doesn't it give you pause--Valentine lived on the same spectrum Angel did.

TBS = headache. Simple TV viewing survival maxim

Smash and Grace sound like potential trainwrecks to me.

Heavenly will rely on casting and looks problematic. However, Saving Grace worked for a bit. This might survive if it has an edge and good writing (of course, it's the CW).

Wonder Woman--I remember DEK's heyday, so I was excited about the prospect of this pilot. Paritcularly since they have nowhere to go but up from Lynda and Lyle's campfest. However, I've seen the desolation that is Harry's Law and the choices already made don't sound promising.

I think Greenwalt's history on Angel, Jake 2.0, and Eureka earn him a little leniency. Tough to tell which of the three magical/fantastical series will be any good.

Big Mike--A&E have their toe in cop dramas and The Glades was a summer success. I'm not wild about Grunberg, but I'll give it a look depending on what else we learn.

Revenge actually sounds like an interesting concept, but I wasn't a fan of Swingtown. Your amusement at Ethan Hawke's desperation is...perplexing.

February 2, 2011 8:24 PM
Nightmare Logic
Reply

Actually some of the Worse Sounding Plots do look promising. Fantasy is my genre of choice and after a couple years of reality, even bad fantasy is better then good (not that there is much of that) reality tv.

Grimm looks promising, and Wonder Woman is something that I will at least look at and hope that the writers don't completly screw it up, And Hallelujah and Once Upon a time are at least getting a looksie.

I'm just happy the pendulum is coming back over to my side of the fantasy/reality devide. I'll take it while I can before reality rears it ugly head.

February 3, 2011 2:24 AM
Totally Not Someone Who Dislikes Zach
Reply

Wait, what? This article is penned by Zack Oak. It is already no longer relevant.

February 3, 2011 8:44 AM
JJ
Reply
replied to comment from Uncle Igmar

I think the point is NOT that Nemesis is calling the writers sexist, but that the THEMES are sexist. Whether or not it really happened, slavery really happened too and I seriously doubt that anyone wants to see three historically accurate "Roots"-type shows.

February 4, 2011 12:37 AM
S.O.
Reply
replied to comment from JJ

That is probably what they meant, but the way it was typed definitely makes it looks like calling the writers sexist.

I think if done right a show about slavery could be interesting. But you're right I wouldn't want more than one.

Loading...

Add a comment

TWoP Toolbar

BLOG ARCHIVES

The Telefile

February 2012

64 Entries

January 2012

78 Entries

December 2011

49 Entries

November 2011

56 Entries

October 2011

74 Entries

September 2011

78 Entries

August 2011

61 Entries

July 2011

56 Entries

June 2011

57 Entries

May 2011

57 Entries

April 2011

78 Entries

March 2011

73 Entries

February 2011

57 Entries

January 2011

65 Entries

December 2010

39 Entries

November 2010

45 Entries

October 2010

46 Entries

September 2010

62 Entries

August 2010

55 Entries

July 2010

53 Entries

June 2010

65 Entries

May 2010

59 Entries

April 2010

57 Entries

March 2010

67 Entries

February 2010

53 Entries

January 2010

59 Entries

December 2009

32 Entries

November 2009

47 Entries

October 2009

65 Entries

September 2009

66 Entries

August 2009

58 Entries

July 2009

72 Entries

June 2009

71 Entries

May 2009

50 Entries

April 2009

57 Entries

March 2009

66 Entries

February 2009

52 Entries

January 2009

56 Entries

December 2008

51 Entries

November 2008

71 Entries

October 2008

88 Entries

September 2008

86 Entries

August 2008

120 Entries

July 2008

115 Entries

June 2008

90 Entries

May 2008

44 Entries

April 2008

30 Entries

March 2008

26 Entries

February 2008

30 Entries

January 2008

44 Entries

December 2007

31 Entries

November 2007

66 Entries